 |
13.(slow.)/JG52
Online & printed reviews
Modelart Australia - February 2008

Flying Scale Models

IPMSUSA.org
Reviewed By John Vitkus, IPMS# 30013
The
somewhat cryptic title refers to the official Luftwaffe designation for
the 13th (Slovak, slowakei in German) Staffel of JG 52 on the Eastern
Front. From December of 1942 through October of 1943, a small group of
29 Slovak fighter pilots were very successful, gaining 215 confirmed
victories over Soviet aircraft at the cost of 4 pilots killed, 2 wounded,
and 3 who defected to the Soviets. However, their luck changed after
being recalled to Slovakia for home defense duties. Now known as the
13th Squadron of the Slovak Air Arms (letka 13, Vzdusne zbrane), they
had only a handful of fighters to counter the American bombers and
escort fighters flying from Italy. In one disastrous mission on 26 June,
1944, eight Slovak Bf-109G-6s joined other Axis fighters to challenge
655 B-17 and B-24 bombers escorted by 290 P-38 and P-51 fighters. One
B-24 was claimed, but six of the eight defending Bf-109Gs were shot down
and another severely damaged, killing three pilots and severely wounding
a fourth. On that day the 13th Squadron, which was in effect the entire
Slovak fighter force, ceased to exist. Later that summer, 15 pilots from
the squadron turned against their former German allies by joining the
the Slovak National Uprising, flying worn out Bf-109s, ancient Avia
B.534 biplane fighters, and other obsolete training planes. The fighting
began in August and ran on for months before it finally failed in
December. During the uprising 8 German aircraft were claimed by Slovak
pilots Two pilots were killed, and two were taken prisoner.
This brief history may sound straightforward, but compiling it was no
easy task. In the decades of communist rule over after WWII, the role of
the 13th Squadron was minimized and distorted to suit the propaganda
needs of the Soviets. Dr. Rajlich, as director of the Historical
Documents section of the Military Historical Institute of Prague,
performed painstaking original research to obtain an objective account
of Slovakia's WWII fighter pilots. He succeeds admirably, delivering a
compelling narrative that kept me eager for the next page. Complementing
his lively text are three tables listing details for (1) the
circumstances of all 215 claims, (2) the victory totals for the 24
pilots who gained at least one combat victory, and (3) the causes of all
53 aircraft lost in operations, whether by accident, bombing, aerial
combat, or defection.
Mushroom Model Publications has another winner here. The book is in
their usual soft cover small-format (9-1/2" X 6-1/2") and contains 112
pages printed on glossy, high-quality paper. Text is in excellent
English throughout, complemented by 180 sharp B/W photos. Maciej
Noszczak and Krzysztof Wolowski provide 23 excellent color profiles of
aircraft, as well as detail artwork showing the evolution of Slovakia's
wartime insignia. This is a must-have volume for anyone with an interest
in the small air forces of WWII It also provides an intriguing
historical background for modelers who are looking for something a
little different when building a B.534 or Bf.109.
Highly recommended!

InternetModeler.com
Reviewed by Chris Banyai-Riepl
The newest in Mushroom’s Blue Series
examines the Slovak squadron of the Luftwaffe’s JG 52. This unit was
responsible for the vast majority of victories for Slovak pilots during
the Second World War, yet its history is not well known. Often dismissed
or completely ignored, the 13th Squadron was little more than a footnote
in the historiography of the Luftwaffe. This book aims to correct that,
providing a very thorough examination of the unit, from its inception in
1939 to its ultimate disbandment in 1944.
The aircraft used by 13. (Slov.) JG 52 were constrained to just two main
types. In 1939, the unit started operations with the Avia B.534, the
classic Czechoslovakian biplane fighter. With this aircraft, the unit
operated in the Polish campaign and the opening moves of Barbarossa, the
invasion of the Soviet Union. Soon after that, though, the squadron
re-equipped with the Messerschmitt Bf 109, and it was with this aircraft
that the unit flew most of its missions. Starting with the Bf 109E
variant, the squadron progressively upgraded their equipment, with the
last flights utilizing the Bf 109G-6. As they were tied to a Luftwaffe
squadron, the camouflage and markings were generally similar to aircraft
in that air force, with just a change in national insignia.
While this book does cover the colors and markings of these aircraft,
the majority of the book is on the operational record of 13. (Slov.) JG
52. This makes for some very interesting reading, as it is well
researched and nicely structured. Drawing on classic references as well
as archival sources, the text tells the story of the pilots and their
missions quite well. This is complimented by the many photographs, some
of which are new. The final pages include comprehensive victory records
and color profiles highlighting many of the individual aircraft flown by
the unit.
This is another outstanding addition to the Mushroom Blue Series, and
one which does great justice to the servicemen of 13. (Slov.) JG 52.
Mini Replika - Polish magazine for
Modellers.

Hyperscale.com
Reviewed by Steven "Modeldad" Eisenman
13. (Slow)
JG 52 is Mushroom Publications latest addition to its Blue Series that
focuses on unit histories and pilot biographies. For those who dont know,
13 Squadron (Slovak) was a component of the Luftwaffes JG 52 and was
comprised of former pilots of the Czechoslovak air force who flew for
the wartime nation of Slovakia.
Whether or not you know about 13. (Slow) JG 52, Im sure you want to know
how this Mushroom Publications compares to the Osprey Aircraft of the
Aces No. 58 Slovakian and Bulgarian Aces of World War 2, especially as
the author of the Mushroom monograph is also one of the authors of the
Osprey monograph.
As one might expect, the two overlap, and to a great extent cover the
same ground. But, there are differences not only in the coverage of the
history, but also in the narratives tone.
Lets start with the historical coverage. The Osprey volume sets out the
historical context both before the creation of 13 (Slow) JG 52 and after
its demise. It begins with the dismemberment of Czechoslovakia, the
creation of the Slovak nation, the Hungarian conflict and ends with a
discussion of the Slovak national uprising.
The Mushroom volume rushes right to the creation of the 13th Squadron as
a result of the military reorganization required by the dismemberment of
Czechoslovakia and the creation of the Slovak Air Arms. It ends with the
mass desertion of 13th Squadron pilots upon the occurrence of the Slovak
uprising. I believe the Osprey monograph does place the role of Slovak
airman in a more understandable historical context.
The other difference between the two is the tone taken by the authors /
author. The Osprey volume is a straightforward historical narrative.
Interesting, but not exciting. On the other hand, the Mushroom monograph
seems to be a bit more polemical and nationalistic. There is a sense of
anger in the writing. This does add more interest, but it also raises
some issues and there are statements that left me scratching my head.
But, both the Germans and Soviets take their fair share of licks at the
hands of Mr. Rajlich.
Whether presented in a more neutral narrative tone or not, it is clear
that the Germans were not exactly the most supportive allies; from
supplying Slovaks with inferior and outdated equipment, to literally
leaving them holding the bag. You also get an understanding of the
Slovak reticence at fighting the Russians, and the Soviets distrust of
defecting Slovak pilots.
In addition to the historical narrative, both books contain numerous
photographs and profiles. However, the photographs in the Mushroom
volume seem more extensive, and better reproduced than those in the
Osprey book. The Mushroom book also seems to include more pictures of
people, in addition to the numerous photographs of the aircraft. While
the profiles in the Osprey volume are more numerous, those in the
Mushroom book are of superior quality.
Finally there are the statistics and combat records. The Mushroom volume
sets forth the confirmed claims of the Slovak airmen in a chronological
order. It also includes a listing of aircraft losses suffered by the
13th Squadron. It must be noted that these lists appear to be confined
to the Eastern Front alone, from October 1942 to October 1943, and does
not include events during the conflict with Hungary and invasion of
Poland, nor does it include action during the defense of Slovakia and
Slovak uprising.
The Osprey publication presents the claims by pilot and does seem to
include periods of combat before and after the dates used in the
Mushroom book. But unlike the Mushroom book, the Osprey edition does not
give any aircraft losses.
Conclusion
So there you have it. The choice is ultimately up to you, but you will
not be disappointed with Mushroom Model Publications' 13 (Slow) JG 52.
Even if you already have the Osprey publication, I found that reading
the Mushroom volume to be a good companion to the Osprey book.
The Mushroom volume provides a most interesting perspective on the 13th
Squadron and for those that enjoy the pictures and graphics, the
Mushroom book delivers a lot.
Skrzydlata Polska - Polish Aviation
Magazine

Air Modeller issue 15, Dec/Jan.

CyberModeler.com
By Ray Mehlberger
This new book by Mushroom Model
Publications (MMP) is in their usual 9” x 6 ½” soft cover format, that
they use for their books on various aircraft subjects. The book is 112
pages in length.
This is the latest volume from MMP in their “Blue Series”. It is a book
on the Slovak fighter unit which fought on the Eastern Front as part of
the Luftwaffe’s JG.52. The history of this unit is described in full,
from its initial establishment following the breakup of Czechoslovakia
by the Nazis, to service with the Germans against the USSR, the
disastrous combats against USAAF bombers and their escorts over Slovakia,
and finally operations against their former ally during the Slovak
uprising in 1944. Initially equipped with the Avia B.534 biplanes, the
unit flew Bf-109’s on the Eastern Front and on home defense, reverting
to B.534 biplanes at the end – and scoring perhaps the final air-to-air
victory by a biplane fighter.
History has not been kind to the 13th Squadron, it’s actions denigrated
or ignored under the post-war communist regime and the subject of
controversy even now. Author Jiri Rajlich PHD studied history at Charles
University in Prague and now works for the Military Historical Institute
in Prague as a director of the Historical Document section. He
specializes in the history of Czechoslovak and Slovak Air Forces and air
combat over Europe during WWII, so is uniquely placed to tell this
story, with full access to all relevant archives and drawing on many
first-hand accounts. He is the author or co-author of more than 40 books
and hundreds of articles on aviation history.
Presented in full for the first time, this is the story of the Slovak
Air Arm’s 13th Squadron. This account tracks the rise and fall of the
13th Squadron from it’s formation in 1939 after the break-up of
Czechoslovakia, through combat on the Eastern Front as part of JG.52, to
tragic efforts defending the homeland against the USAAF, and finally
action against it’s former allies, the Germans, at the end of WWII.
With it’s history distorted and discredited under Czechoslovak communist
rule, the true story of this very successful fighter unit can now be
told.
The book is profusely illustrated with 184 black and white wartime
photos of the aircraft and pilots of the 13th Squadron. There are 15
pages of data lists. At the end of the book, there are 23 color profile
paintings of aircraft in Czech and Slovak markings. These include the
Avia B.534, Bf-109E-3, E-4, E-7, G-4 and G-6. The book has full details
of all claimed victories by 13/JG.52, plus it’s losses, and details of
the aircraft flown by the unit.
This is an invaluable reference source for aircraft historians,
enthusiasts and scale modelers.
ModelingMadness.com
Reviewer: Scott Van Aken
One of the
lesser known air forces of WWII is that of Slovakia, a country formed by
the German invasion of early 1939. When the Germans went to war with the
Soviets, it was 'requested' that the Slovaks provide military units to
help in the fighting. One of those was 13 squadron of the Slovak Air
Force.
This unit had been formed from the combining of several other ex-Czech
squadrons whose aircraft were in Slovak territory, so their main
equipment was the B.534, a fine, but obsolescent aircraft. After some
use of this aircraft, it was obvious that something newer was needed so
Slovakia bought a number of what they assumed were relatively new
Bf-109E-7s. After training pilots in Germany, these men brought home the
planes they had been training on; mostly worn out 109E-2/3/4/7 aircraft.
But they were the most modern aircraft available.
Pilots of this unit fought in JG 52 on the eastern front. When the 109Es
were determined to be outclassed, these men used standard German 109G
aircraft, sending the Es home for air defense. The only markings that
differentiated the Slovak Gs from regular Luftwaffe planes was the
national colors on the tip of the spinner.
The men of this unit were initially quite successful with a number of
aces and a considerable number of victories to their credit. Though
morale suffered as the war situation worsened, for the most part, they
continued to fight. Eventually some defected to the Russians while
others fought with the Slovak Uprising in 1944.
Though their feats were denigrated or ignored by the Communist regime,
their story is told in full as it is now known in these pages. As with
other Mushroom Model titles, it is lavishly illustrated with period
photos and a goodly number of superb color profiles. A full appendix
that includes victories and losses is also in with the book.
It is a superb read of a part of the war that few realize took place. A
book I know you will enjoy reading and one I can highly recommend.
|